Section 50C not applicable to builder assessee in Property Redevelopment case
Redevelopment projects are the real estate projects where old construction is destroyed on the grounds of the same being of obsolete and probably of risk to the members of the society. In such situations builders approaches members of the society or vice-versa to form an agreement for redevelopment of the society and offer flats to existing members either for the existing area or enhanced area as approved or offering them with additional area upon payment of consideration for such additional space. An issue relating to income of such real estate developers was dealt by ITAT where assessing officers proposed to invoke provisions of Section 50C in relation to capital gains Issues Involved:The case of Assessee Tirupati Developers, a partnership firm engaged in the business of builders and developers was selected for scrutiny for the reason that specific information was received from sub registrar office that the assessee has sold immovable property on 29.07.2017 for consideration of Rs.10,00,000/- whereas the market value of the said property is Rs.40,42,000. Assessing officer made an addition of difference amount under section 50C of income tax act. Contention of assessee was that he was involved in the business of builders and developers, hence the provisions of Section 50C will not apply in this case as those provisions are with respect to capital gains. Facts of the case explained:The case of assessee belongs to AY 2018-19, where assessee filed the return of income for assessment year 2018-19 declaring income at nil. The case was selected for scrutiny. Aggrieved assesssee filed appeal before CIT(A) which was dismissed by CIT(A). CIT(A) upheld the decision of AO to add the difference amount as income. Aggrieved assessee filed an appeal at Tribunal. Assessee argued that addition is made on the basis of a misunderstood fact that the assessee has sold flat whereas the assessee has sold only the additional area of the flat purchased by the member of the society as per the agreement. Assessee submitted that the assessee is engaged in the business of builders and developers and declares the profit on sale of flats as income from business the provisions of section 50C of the Act are not applicable to the assessee. Accordingly it was submitted that the addition made by the assessing officer under section 50C is not tenable. As per clauses mentioned in the agreement between the asssessee and the members of the society, it is clear that the consideration is received only for the additional area and not for the entire flat. Conclusion:Assessee being a Builder and Developer of property has offered the income from project of redevelopment under the head of and gains from business or profession following Project Completion Method and therefore the addition made by the assessing officer is not tenable. Mumbai Bench of ITAT has therefore expressed that provisions of Section 50C cannot be invoked in this case as the income of the assessee is through profits and gains from business profession and not through capital gains. About Author:CA Chinmay Shirish AgateChinmay Agate is a Practicing Chartered Accountant having 4+ years of experience and expertise in the field of Direct Taxation and Auditing compliances. In the past, he worked in various CA firms and comes with wide industry experience from services, retail to manufacturing to trading where he has handled various complex assignments. He has keen interest in Forex and Derivative knowledge as well as fundamental analysis.
No capital gain tax on transfer of shares by way of Gifts : Bombay HC
Transfer of shares by way of GiftsCapital gain taxes are levied upon transfer of capital assets. Transfer in general sense means sale of such capital assets when capital assets in question are shares of a company. However, there are certain transfers of capital assets which are not regarded as transfers and hence such are not liable to be taxed under the head of Income from Capital Gains. Bombay HC has decided in the case of M/s Jai trust regarding such transfers which are not considered as transfers. Issues involved:M/s Jai trust had transferred certain shares to a private limited company by way of gifts and hence no consideration was involved. The department had raised objections and applied for reopening of assessment on the grounds that such transfer of shares is income escaped assessment and chargeable to tax. The assessee had challenged legality and reopening of such assessment. Facts of the case explained:M/s Jai trust being the petitioner, had transferred 30,65,600 shares of United Phosphorus Limited (UPL) and 3,06,560 shares of Uniphos Enterprises Limited (UEL) both public listed companies to one Nerka Chemicals Private Limited (NCPL) by way of a gift in terms of Transfer Deed dated 26th February 2010. Since the shares were transferred by way of gift, no consideration was received by petitioner. Under section 47(iii), any transfer of a capital asset under a gift or will or an irrevocable trust is not considered as a transfer. Exception is given where transfer under a gift or an irrevocable trust of a capital asset being shares, debentures or warrants allotted by a company directly or indirectly to its employees under any Employees’ Stock Option Plan or any employee scheme. This issue under consideration was for AY 2010-11. On 22nd July 2010 petitioner filed its return of income for Assessment Year 2010-2011 declaring total income as Nil. This was because the income of petitioner was distributed in the hands of the beneficiaries. Petitioner received notice for reopening the assessment and in reply the petitioner filed its objections. Assessing Officer must have reason to believe that income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment prior to the initiation of the proceedings. This condition is not complied with in the present case because there cannot be any reason to believe that income has escaped assessment because there is no income that could be assessed to tax. In this case, provisions of Section 45 related to transfer of shares and provisions of section 47 related to transactions not treated as transfer clearly indicates that transfer of shares in the form of gift will not be liable to tax as there is no consideration is involved in the case. Conclusion:Any capital assets being transferred will generate capital gain tax liabilities only when the consideration is involved and provisions of income tax allows it. In the present case the reopening of such assessment will not be valid if there is no income escaping assessment. The HC after observing all the facts of such petition quashed the reassessment notice. About Author:CA Chinmay Shirish AgateChinmay Agate is a Practicing Chartered Accountant having 4+ years of experience and expertise in the field of Direct Taxation and Auditing compliances. In the past, he worked in various CA firms and comes with wide industry experience from services, retail to manufacturing to trading where he has handled various complex assignments. He has keen interest in Forex and Derivative knowledge as well as fundamental analysis.
Income of Charitable Trusts
A charitable trust is a non-profit organization which is established for the purpose of betterment of society in general or to support a specific section of the society. Upliftment of such sections of the society is general motive of the charitable trusts. Keeping in mind this very nature of the charitable trusts, income tax act provides certain exemptions to charitable trusts. These exemptions are only available for specific types of income. Such trusts must fulfil certain conditions in order to claim these exemptions. Provisions relating to taxation of such charitable trusts are dealt with in accordance with section 11 of the Income Tax Act, 1961. Section 11 of the Income Tax Act:The purpose of a charitable or religious organisation is to carry out activities for which such entities are set up. Section 11 provides an income tax exemption where income derived from property held under charitable trusts and institutions. In order to claim these exemptions, such income must be derived from properties that are operating solely for religious or charitable purposes. Additionally, the entities must obtain a registration certificate under Section 12A or Section 12AA of the Income Tax Act. For obtaining exemption from tax under Section 11, few other conditions are also required to be fulfilled: Following is a list of incomes which are exempt from tax under section 11 of the Income Tax Act: As mentioned in the above provisions, 85% of income from property should be applied to charitable or religious activities. However, what if 85% of income is not applied? If a trust or institution is unable to apply 85% of its income from property held under them, the exemption from tax on income is still available if the following conditions are satisfied: Application of funds:Section 11 has prescribed modes for utilisation of such 85% of revenue from property. The 85% funds amount will not be considered as income if : Section 11(5) of the IT Act deals with the modes of investment prescribed under Section 11 which can be immovable properties, investments in certain government saving certificates, Savings certificates and other securities or certificates issued by the Central Government, various shares, deposits with posts or UTIs etc. Conclusion:A charitable trust is the non-profit sector, designed to support and advance various public welfare causes and charitable as well as religious activities. Section 11 provides exemptions from tax to such institutions adhering to the provisions mentioned in the income tax act. To put it in brief, section 11 allows 15% of the income of such institutions to be kept for use other than for charitable purposes ro religious purposes. Rest of the 85% of contributions received are supposed to be utilised for such charitable purposes subject to fulfilment of certain other conditions. About Author:CA Chinmay Shirish AgateChinmay Agate is a Practicing Chartered Accountant having 4+ years of experience and expertise in the field of Direct Taxation and Auditing compliances. In the past, he worked in various CA firms and comes with wide industry experience from services, retail to manufacturing to trading where he has handled various complex assignments. He has keen interest in Forex and Derivative knowledge as well as fundamental analysis.
What is transfer in Capital Gains
In income tax act, capital gains are taxed upon transfer of capital assets. Capital assets are defined in Section 2(14) of Income Tax Act, 1961. The concept of transfer is discussed in definition of transfer under section 2(47). Capital gains arises where a capital asset is transferred for a consideration. However, there are certain transactions which are not regarded as transfer. In this article, we will discuss in detail the meaning of transfer for the purpose of income tax. Transfer:In simple terms, transfer in the context of capital gains means exchange of ownership or authority of a particular asset for consideration. Section 2(47) defines transfer as, transfer in relation to a capital asset, includes: Transfer includes disposing of or parting with an asset or any interest therein, or creating any interest in any asset by way of an agreement (whether entered into in India or outside India) or otherwise. Transfer of a capital asset coupled with a valid form of consideration will amount to the capital gain income. To arrive at capital gains, various costs and expenses are deducted from the sale value or from the full value of consideration. These include cost of indexation, cost of improvement and other expenses of capital nature. Cost of acquisition is the value for which the capital asset was acquired by the seller. Cost of improvement is expenses of a capital nature incurred in making any additions or alterations to the capital asset by the seller. Transactions which are not considered as transfer are exclusively mentioned in section 47 of Income Tax Act, 1961. Capital assets based on their holding period are identified as Short term or Long term capital assets. Any gains or losses arising on transfer of such assets will be accordingly identified as STCL/STCG or LTCL/LTCG. Rates of taxes upon such transfers also varies based on nature of assets that whether it is a Short term or Long term capital asset. Conclusion:Selling, gifting, or transferring assets through inheritance, requires a detailed understanding of these provisions which can help in effective tax planning and compliance. Knowing which transactions are transfers and which are not is an important aspect to determine taxability of such transactions. About Author:CA Chinmay Shirish AgateChinmay Agate is a Practicing Chartered Accountant having 4+ years of experience and expertise in the field of Direct Taxation and Auditing compliances. In the past, he worked in various CA firms and comes with wide industry experience from services, retail to manufacturing to trading where he has handled various complex assignments. He has keen interest in Forex and Derivative knowledge as well as fundamental analysis.
No deduction for expenditure on Freebies given to doctors by Pharmaceutical Companies
Many pharmaceutical companies have a strategy to distribute their promotional materials to various medical practitioners. These include small quantities of medications given to doctors by pharmaceutical companies to be provided to patients, branded pens, notepads, calendars, or other office supplies with the pharmaceutical company’s logo or medical equipments etc. There are concerns that freebies could influence medical practitioner’s decisions, potentially leading to conflicts of interest. Such pharma companies many times claims the deduction of such expenses on freebies given for the purpose of reducing profits and ultimately leading to lesser taxes. However, Ahmedabad bench of ITAT has disallowed such expenses. Issues involved:The assessee company has claimed deduction of certain business advancement expenses incurred in the form of promotional expenses for its manufactured pharmaceutical products. Assessing officer found that such expenses are expenses prohibited by law to be allowed as deductions under section 37 of The Income Tax Act. Whether assessing officer is right in disallowing such expenses? Facts of the case explained:The assessee company torrent pharmaceutical limited is engaged in manufacturing and marketing of pharmaceutical products. The assessee company had claimed certain expenses under the head selling and distribution expenses which were originally incurred for distribution of various brochures, literature specifying its products, new development, research activities, gifts distributed to doctors, wholesalers or retailers etc.. Assessing officer stated that such expenses are in violation of Indian Medical Council of India regulations in exercise of power conferred under Section 33 of Indian Medical Council Act 1956. Three types of expenses were claimed by the assessee company which are: (1) Business Advancement Expenses Rs. 53,06,10,021/-(2) Sales Promotion Expenses Rs. 3,77,89,705/-(3) Doctor’s Sponsorship Rs. 19,63,90,203/- As per the assessee, these expenditures were incurred in the ordinary course of business to create its brand, goodwill, and trade relationship. On the other hand, AO found that the expenses incurred for the benefits of doctor cannot be allowed under the provision of section 37 of the Act, as the same were incurred in violation of regulation issued by the Indian Medical Council in exercise of power conferred under section 33 of Indian Medical Council Act 1956. This was supported with a circular of CBDT no.05/2012 dated 01/08/2012 prohibiting the deduction of such expenses. Therefore, the AO disallowed 100% of the expenditure incurred under the head “Doctor’s Sponsorship” amounting to Rs. 19,63,90,203/- only. Likewise, the AO found that the assessee failed to establish that the expenses incurred under the head “Business Advancement and Sales Promotion” do not include the expenditure in connection with doctor benefit. The assessee also failed to furnish any detail specifying the amount not incurred/ falling under the category of doctor benefits. Thus, the AO in absence of necessary details proceeded to estimate the expenditure for doctor’s benefit included under the head “Business Advancement and Sales Promotion” @ 10% of such expenditures and accordingly disallowed an amount of Rs. 5,30,61,002/- and Rs. 37,78,978/- respectively. The CBDT vide circular No. 05/2012 dated 01-08-2012 clarified that expenditure incurred by the pharmaceutical sector industries in the nature of freebie to medical professionals are in violation of above mentioned regulation of MCI and therefore, such expenditure will not be allowed as deduction to the pharmaceutical sector industries under the provision of explanation to Section 37(1) of the Income Tax Act being expenses incurred for a purpose which is either an offense or prohibited by law. Conclusion:Maintaining the values which do not violate conflict of interest are of the utmost importance to professionals from medical field. Pharma sector companies providing such professionals with gifts or freebies to promote their business do not fall under allowable expenses as per income tax act. Therefore, AO disallowed 100% of such expenses and an estimated 10% amount of business promotion and selling expenses where assessee failed to submit any documentary evidence in its support. About Author:CA Chinmay Shirish AgateChinmay Agate is a Practicing Chartered Accountant having 4+ years of experience and expertise in the field of Direct Taxation and Auditing compliances. In the past, he worked in various CA firms and comes with wide industry experience from services, retail to manufacturing to trading where he has handled various complex assignments. He has keen interest in Forex and Derivative knowledge as well as fundamental analysis.
Deduction of expenses for businesses on payment basis only
While computing income for the source of income from business and profession, certain expenses are allowed as deduction from such incomes or receipts. While doing accounting of such businesses expenses are recorded on accrual or receipts whichever is earlier. Income tax also recognises this principle of accounting and accepts the same. However, there are certain expenses which can be claimed only in the year in which they are paid and not in the year in which their liability to pay incurs. Section 43B of income tax delas with the provisions of payments allowed as deductions only on the payment basis. Section 43B:Section 43B of the Income Tax Act provides a list of expenses allowed as deductions under the heading ‘Income from business and profession’ only when they are actually paid by the assessee. Following is a list of expenses where section 43B is applicable for such expenses that are allowed only if dues are paid within the time limit specified in The Income Tax Act: Clause 43B(h) as amended in Finance Act, 2023 This amendment is applicable to any sum payable by the assessee to a micro or small enterprise beyond the time limit specified under section 15 of the MSMED Act, 2006. This clause only applies to micro and small enterprises, while medium enterprises stay out of the purview of this act. Section 15 of the MSMED Act determines the time limits for payments to be made to the MSMEs. Timeframes to make payments to MSMEs when: Conditions for claiming deductions under section 43B:Following conditions are to be complied mandatorily in order to claim deductions u/s 43B: It is important to note that converting interest liabilities into share capital is not covered by Section 43B of the Income Tax Act. Conclusion:Deduction of expenses mentioned are mandatorily required to be paid within due date in order to ensure timely compliance with the respective authorities. The amendment to clause (h) of Section 43B is an important step in bringing the desired change in payment structure of businesses to ensure timely and prompt payments to MSEs. Disallowance of expenses upon failure to pay within due date will put additional taxation liabilities on the businesses. About Author:CA Chinmay Shirish AgateChinmay Agate is a Practicing Chartered Accountant having 4+ years of experience and expertise in the field of Direct Taxation and Auditing compliances. In the past, he worked in various CA firms and comes with wide industry experience from services, retail to manufacturing to trading where he has handled various complex assignments. He has keen interest in Forex and Derivative knowledge as well as fundamental analysis.