No TDS is applicable u/s 194H in B2B Transactions if assessee is not responsible for paying Income Tax or Filing Income Tax Returns: Supreme Court
Deduction of tax at source from income has been one of the most crucial part of compliance for every set of persons as prescribed by law. Provisions of Deduction of Tax at source are attracted upon fulfilment of certain conditions where one person has to deduct tax at source from income of another person. As per judgement dated 28th February, 2024; Supreme court of India upon hearing the matter in Civil Appeal No. 7257 of 2011 & Ors. between revenue and assessee(Bharti Airtel Ltd.) decided and ordered that there is no requirement of deduction of TDS u/s 194H, where assessee had given discounts to its distributors or franchisees and such distributors and franchisees sold the product to third parties at a price which was higher than the price at which they received due to the discount component. Issues Involved: There were agreements between assessee and distributors/franchisees where assessee provided products to these distributors/franchisees at a discounted price. As per revenue, this amounts to commission when these distributor/franchisees sell these products to third partie/final consumers. Therefore, assessee is liable to deduct TDS u/s 194H. Whereas as per assessee i.e. (Bharti Cellular Limited now Bharti Airtel Limited) a cellular mobile services provider, neither they are paying a commission or brokerage to the franchisees/distributors, nor are the franchisees/distributors their agents. Whether assessee is required to deduct TDS for the income/profit component in the payments received by the distributors/franchisees from the third parties/customers, or while selling/transferring the pre-paid coupons or starter-kits to the distributors? What does section 194H says? Section 194H of the Income Tax Act deals with TDS deduction on the payment of commission or brokerage. It mandates tax deduction by the person (other than individual/HUF) responsible for paying commission or brokerage to resident persons at the rate of 5% when the amount exceeds Rs.15,000 during a financial year. TDS under section 194H of the Income Tax Act shall also be deducted by all the individuals and HUFs (Hindu Undivided Family) who are required to get their accounts audited under section 44AB. However, it does not include insurance commission, as provided in section 194D. Explanation given in the order of Supreme Court: The assessees, (Bharti Airtel Limited) – A cellular mobile service providers, had entered into franchise/distribution agreements related to their prepaid connections, selling start-up kits and recharge vouchers at a discounted price to franchisee/distributors. The dispute arose regarding whether the assessees should deduct tax at source on the income/profit component in payments received by franchisees/distributors from third parties/customers. The assessees explained that they were not paying commission or brokerage to franchisees/distributors and that they were not acting as agents for them. In order to increase their marketing and customer base they were merely giving discounts to franchisees/distributors. On the other hand, the Revenue argued that the difference between the discounted price and sale price constituted income for franchisees/distributors, making them agents eligible for tax deduction under Section 194-H. The court emphasized on the Section 182 of Indian Contract Act, 1872 to determine the nature of relation, i.e., whether it constitutes a Principal- Agent relationship. Deduction of Tax at source in this situation arises only when the Principal-Agent relationship exists. The income of franchisee/distributor in the form of discounts is not credited by the assessees, and they are not liable to oversee transactions taking place between distributors/franchisees and third parties/customers. Contrary opinions among various High Courts existed. Delhi and Calcutta High ruled in favour of Tax Deduction whereas HC of Rajasthan, Bombay and Karnataka ruled otherwise. Conclusion: The Supreme Court held that Section 194-H is not applicable in this case. It was observed that although the discounted price is determined by contract and negotiated between the assessees and franchisee/distributor, the sale price or the final price in the form of sale consideration received by the franchisee/distributor is at their sole discretion, and the assessees could not have any authority over regulating such prices. Accordingly, appeals filed by assessee, challenging judgements of Delhi and Calcutta HC are allowed and the judgements set aside. Appeals filed by Revenue challenging judgements of HC of Rajasthan, Karnataka and Bombay were dismissed.
Rebate under section 87A of Income Tax Act, 1961
Introduction: In India, tax planning has been one of the most worrisome factor for common individuals and corporates who are not well aware of the benefits available to them. However, government of India has given certain special benefits to Individuals for reducing their burden of taxes when the belong to a particular income level category. It is a common practice that individuals make vast and diverse kind of investments to save taxes on their income through various channels. But there is a kind of special benefit given to individuals where they get a rebate in tax amount without investing even a single rupee to avail this rebate. This comes with various certain mandatory conditions. What is rebate in income tax act? A rebate is a special benefit provided by government to individual taxpayers. This allows taxpayers to reduce their tax liability to certain extent. It is a reduction in the amount of tax payable by individuals. The amount of rebate one can claim varies depend upon the nature of investment or expenditure they incur. Rebate under Section 87A of Income Tax Act, 1961: Rebate under section 87A is available only to a “Resident Individual”. Any resident individual whose Total Income does not exceed Rs.5,00,000 is entitled to claim this deduction from the amount of income-tax. This deduction is available upto 100% of his tax liability which means if his total income is upto Rs.5,00,000 after claiming all the deductions available to him except the deduction under this section the his entire amount of income tax is reduced to Nil. However, this amount of tax rebate is restricted to Rs.12,500/-. This means any amount of tax on income upto Rs.5,00,000 is the amount of rebate one will receive or Rs.12,500, whichever is higher. The above mentioned explaination is with regards to the old regime of Income Tax Act. Rebate under section 87A of Income Tax Act, 1961 as per New Regime: Budget 2023 proposed several amendments with a view to make new tax regime more adaptable to all classes of persons. Income upto Rs.7,00,000 is the new limit to claim rebate under section 87A as per new tax regime. The amount of Rebate is increased to Rs.25,000 or actual tax amount on income upto Rs.7,00,000, whichever is higher. The deduction is available to resident individuals only in new tax regime as well. Conclusion: It is clear that the Tax rebate under section 87A is available to old tax regime as well as new tax regime. However, limits of income and tax rebates are still different for both the regimes. One has to keep in mind while preparing income tax returns that the rebate under section 87A is available to Resident individuals only and not even available to NRIs or HUFs.
Defective Income Tax Return and its reasons
Defective Income Tax Return:Filing of Income Tax Return every year is the compliance every person must undertake if he falls within the specified category of Income Tax. In India, every person who is liable to file Income Tax Return faces the challenge of correctly filing the return and not getting any notices or scrutiny form Income Tax Department. A Defective return is a one which has errors, omissions, or inconsistencies that prevent income tax department from completing the processing of return. Mistakes, omission of information or instances like entering data into incorrect ITR Forms will make a return defective. As per section 139(9) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, when a return is found defective, the A.O. gives you a period of 15 days to correct the mistake. Why does a return become defective?Assessing Officer while processing a return will consider following matters to decide whether a return is defective: If all the details which are required to be reported or entered in the return are omitted or if mandatory annexures, statements or schedules are not entered then the return becomes defective. If all the taxes are paid like TDS, Self assessment or Advance tax but their details are not mentioned in the ITR then, the return becomes defective. When either TDS is deducted or any other type of tax is paid but corresponding income is not offered for tax in ITR. When mandatory books of accounts are not maintained as per the act. All the mandatory provisions required to be fulfilled are omitted or incomplete compliance is done. For e.g. Taxpayer having income under the head “Profits and gains of Business or Profession” but has not filled Balance Sheet and Profit and Loss Account. In case of audit provisions, if the concerned audit report is not submitted within time or an incomplete audit report is submitted then return may become defective. The assessee is required to conduct a cost audit as per mandatory provisions, but fails to provide detailed information of the same. When the name mentioned in the ITR does not match with the records in the PAN databse. In ITR 4, the profit percentage as mentioned in the provisions are to be maintained. This means if the profit percentage is shown at less than 6 % or 8 % as required, then the return becomes defective. How to Respond to Defective Return Notice u/s 139(9)?Upon receipt of a defective tax return notice, assessee must respond within 15 days to A.O. In following ways he must respond to the notice: Failure to do so will result in levying of interest, penalty, disallowance of exemptions or deductions etc. This will ultimately result in becoming the return invalid. Conclusion:Receiving a notice for defective income tax return is not a worrying factor as one gets enough time and opportunity to correct the mistakes however, correct reporting while filing ITR is a more appropriate approach. In taxbase, we have adequate tools implemented to guide the users where chances of getting a defective return are minimized if all the information entered is correct and in appropriate manner. Before submitting the ITR if any errors are pertaining in it, then taxbase will notify the user of probable outcome of defective return. Also, in case of any receipt of defective return, it shows the guide to correctly respond to it. About Author: CA Chinmay Shirish AgateChinmay Agate is a Practicing Chartered Accountant having 4+ years of experience and expertise in the field of Direct Taxation and Auditing compliances. In the past, he worked in various CA firms and comes with wide industry experience from services, retail to manufacturing to trading where he has handled various complex assignments. He has keen interest in Forex and Derivative knowledge as well as fundamental analysis.
LEI number in ITR
Cash Withdrawals or Cash deposits and its implications as per Income Tax
Introduction:Cash transactions have always been the major component of Indian economy before the introduction of banking systems. With the regulatory mechanisms of the banks, cash transactions became an escape path for people trying to hide their actual income and evade the tax. In order to promote transperancy in business, government of India started putting stringent restrictions on cash trasactions in businesses. People hoarding cash of substantial limits were put under the radar of income tax department. Money laundering became a common term of use when it came to topics of discussion about cash transactions. In this article, we have explained implications of cash deposits and cash withdrawals as per current market scenarios. Limits for Cash Deposits:Income tax departments have put certain limits on cash deposits in banks. Depositing an amount exceeding Rs.10 lakh in a single or combined financial year attracts attention from the Income Tax Department. Any cash deposit transactions exceeding Rs.10 lakhs in a financial year across all your savings accounts is duly reported to the Income tax department. The Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) requires banks to report such transactions. One may face scrutiny notices from the department if such amount exceeds Rs.10Lakhs. High-value transaction reporting portal promptly reflects your substantial transactions in cash such as making credit card bill payments in cash of more than Rs.1Lakh or making any purchase of high value in cash etc. Limits for Cash Withdrawals:If cash deposits are to face such stringent compliances, then it is obvious that the cash withdrawals will have additional measures for compliances. Income Tax Department has notified a Section 194N to apply TDS on cash withdrawals. According to section 194N of the Act, TDS has to be deducted if a person withdraws in cash any amount in a particular FY if it exceeds : Rate of applicable TDS under section 194N: Exceptions under section 194N i.e. in case of following persons no TDS is to be deducted if cash withdrawals exceed the specified limits: Conclusion:Income tax laws are framed in India to monitor legal usage of funds and to avoid any kind of illegal activity like money laundering, havala or terror-financing etc., which may hamper Indian economy in and adverse way. When the cash transactions are monitored frequently and strictly, then such issues may be addressed properly. Levying of TDS on certain transactions leads to government having an eye over the activities happening in the economy. At the same hand, Income tax department have exempted certain persons from such provisions keeping in mind their nature of activities. About Author: CA Chinmay Shirish AgateChinmay Agate is a Practicing Chartered Accountant having 4+ years of experience and expertise in the field of Direct Taxation and Auditing compliances. In the past, he worked in various CA firms and comes with wide industry experience from services, retail to manufacturing to trading where he has handled various complex assignments. He has keen interest in Forex and Derivative knowledge as well as fundamental analysis.